Your login screen is the front door to your application. If the key doesn't work, it's a terrible first impression. That's the problem we saw happening with magic links.
This feature is supposed to be simple and secure. In reality, it often creates confusion. A user gets a link, bookmarks it, and then comes back later to find it's useless. They're locked out and frustrated.
We noticed this pattern at Insero. Instead of just calling it user error, we wanted to dig in and find the root cause. We actually tasked one of our AI colleagues, Rick Research, to analyze the problem from the ground up.
His findings confirmed a key principle of user experience. The problem isn't the user. The problem is that magic links go against decades of learned behavior.
Think about it. We have all spent our entire digital lives learning a simple formula: username + password = login. Our brain associates a link with a permanent destination, like a browser favorite.
Rick's analysis showed that a magic link, which is temporary and only works once, completely breaks this mental model. This is why people intuitively save the link, because that’s what a link is supposed to be for. This core misunderstanding creates a few obvious problems.
First, the process itself can be clunky. The user has to leave your app, open their email, find the specific message (and hope it isn't in spam), then click back. On a phone, this can be even worse if the link opens in a separate browser and breaks the login flow.
Second, the name "magic link" doesn't explain what it does. It sounds easy, but its temporary nature isn't obvious at all.
Getting rid of magic links isn't the answer. For some people, they’re a great way to avoid managing another password. The real solution, as Rick's research pointed out, is to give users a choice and guide them properly.
Here is the straightforward strategy we built.
1. Make Password Login the Default The first thing you see on our login page is the traditional email and password fields. This is the familiar path. It’s what most people expect, so it creates zero confusion.
2. Offer the Magic Link as a Clear Alternative Just below the main login form, we offer the second option. We didn't use a vague button, the button clearly states the action: "Send me the link."
To make it even clearer, we added a short, simple explanation right underneath:
You will receive a link that can be used once to log in without a password.
3. Use Clear Communication and Error Messages After a user requests a link, they get an immediate confirmation on the screen:
Check your inbox! We've sent a single-use login link to your email. It's valid for 1 hour.
The email also contains clear instruction that the link can only be used once. What if they click an expired link? We send them to a page that explains exactly what happened and gives them a button to request a new one. No dead ends.
A good login experience is the very first promise you deliver to your users. By putting their expectations first, the benefits are clear. You get happier users who aren't stuck before they can even start. Your support team gets to focus on bigger problems than explaining why a link has expired.
Most importantly, it builds trust. It shows you respect your users and are thoughtful about the technology you build.
At Insero, we believe technology should work for people, not the other way around. It’s a philosophy that guides everything we do, including how we build AI colleagues that solve real business problems. It all starts with getting the fundamentals right.
Ready to see what a smarter approach to technology can do for your team? Start Your Free Trial
.webp)
